What Matters
When someone promises ‘4% on cash’ and someone else advertises ‘6% on stablecoins’, the higher number is not automatically the better place to park funds. The comparison crosses different legal claims: bank deposits, direct Treasury debt, money-market fund shares and crypto yield arrangements.
DN’s cross-rail framework separates a narrow, calculable question—what the quoted rates leave after known fees—from harder questions about principal, custody, redemption and who is authorised to hold the product.
1. Insured bank deposit or money-market deposit account
A bank savings or money-market deposit account is a deposit claim. At an FDIC-insured US bank, eligible deposits can be protected up to applicable limits and ownership categories. A money-market deposit account is not a money-market mutual fund.
Evidence gate: Confirm bank charter, exact legal account, rate, fees, deposit insurance and withdrawal terms. Insurance rules in the US do not automatically apply to a South African account.
2. Direct short-term Treasury bill
A Treasury bill is a debt obligation of the US government, not an FDIC-insured bank deposit. The quoted Treasury yield is not necessarily the net yield realized by a reader who buys through an intermediary or sells before maturity.
Evidence gate: Confirm bill maturity, auction/secondary purchase price, custody, access, bid-ask spread, transaction costs and any currency conversion.
3. Money-market mutual fund
A money-market fund is an investment fund, not a money-market deposit account. It may hold cash, very short-term government debt or other eligible assets, with fees and redemption terms based on fund structure; shares are not FDIC-insured.
Evidence gate: Confirm the specific government, prime or tax-exempt fund, net yield, share class, NAV behavior, liquidity fees, gate restrictions if applicable, and settlement.
4. Stablecoin yield account or protocol
Holding an ordinary dollar-denominated stablecoin does not automatically earn interest. Yield products add a separate arrangement: custody, lending, market-making, tokenized instruments or derivatives. Stablecoins and the product may carry issuer, smart-contract, liquidation and redemption risk.
Evidence gate: Verify who owes the yield, whether the return is variable, pool reserves, provider permissions, token redemption rights, lock terms and the bank payout route.
The protection map
| Instrument | Legal claim | Exit dependency |
|---|---|---|
| Insured bank deposit or money-market deposit account | Deposit claim with applicable bank coverage | Bank and account withdrawal conditions |
| Direct short-term Treasury bill | Direct US sovereign debt; no FDIC deposit insurance | Maturity or sale to a buyer; settlement and taxes |
| Money-market mutual fund | Mutual fund shares; not FDIC-insured | Fund dealing and redemption procedures |
| Stablecoin yield account or protocol | Token or protocol claim plus separate yield-generating arrangement | Issuer, custodian, chain, protocol and off-ramp conditions |
DN Cash vs Stablecoin Yield: After-Cost Scenario Calculator
Enter hypothetical or current provider-verified rates for four different instruments. Annual rate, annual fees and flat round-trip costs are deliberately separate. The output compares only illustrative short-horizon cash arithmetic. It cannot price deposit insurance, default risk, missed redemptions or tax.
Bank deposit
Treasury bill
Money-market fund
Stablecoin yield product
Why the word ‘money market’ is dangerous without the word after it
The US FDIC deposit-insurance guide lists eligible bank money-market deposit accounts among deposit products, subject to ownership and insurance limits, but explicitly excludes mutual funds, securities and crypto assets from deposit insurance. The SEC’s money-market funds investor guide describes fund shares as investments, not insured deposits, whose net assets and redemption terms depend on the fund. An insured deposit account and a money-market mutual fund can have similar-looking yields while exposing holders to different rights.
What Treasury rates do and do not mean
The US Treasury’s official November 2026 daily T-bill rates provide a dated reference for discount and investment yields by maturity; the raw series is not a quote a reader can necessarily transact at after brokerage, spread and custody. We have deliberately not placed any current quote into the worksheet, because yields change by day and a reader’s instrument, country and term affect what is actually available.
What the stablecoin issuer says
Circle’s USDC terms, updated October 15, 2026 say USDC holders do not receive interest on issuer reserves merely by holding USDC. They distinguish eligible Circle Mint clients from other holders, and note the lack of deposit insurance. A yield product offered by a lender, exchange, vault or derivative arrangement therefore adds a separate contractual and counterparty layer. Do not label a custody account ‘cash’ simply because it tracks USD.
Method and comparison limitations
The calculator uses simple prorated non-compounded rates for a user-entered period, minus annual drag and fixed round-trip costs. For example, a hypothetical 6% yield with 0.7 percentage-point annual drag and $45 of entry/exit costs produces a different 90-day result from its headline. That does not imply a 6% stablecoin product is accessible, currently offered, insured or safer than a Treasury bill. Tax, exchange rates, redemption haircuts and principal loss are intentionally outside the model rather than concealed in invented probability discounts.
The source-review date is 18 November 2026. We did not place real customer funds, test actual withdrawals or publish a risk-adjusted provider ranking from this comparison.
How this fits DN’s existing research
The Real Stablecoin Yield Ranking analyzes different crypto yield strategies and their risk assumptions. The Tokenized Treasury Yield Leakage Index investigates tokenized fund economics. Those are product-specific tools; this article answers the earlier decision of whether the reader is even comparing comparable instruments.
Optional commercial pathways, without a yield recommendation
For South African readers evaluating crypto exchanges as a *separate* access route, DN’s referral links include VALR and Luno. These are affiliate referrals; product availability, actual yield, tax consequences, currency conversion and withdrawal rights must be verified independently. No particular exchange, stablecoin or yield product is endorsed, and this page does not promote leveraged strategies.
Frequently asked questions
Is a 4% stablecoin yield the same as a 4% insured bank interest rate?
No. The nominal percentage cannot convey different redemption rights, platform/counterparty risk, insurance eligibility, access and tax.
Are money-market deposit accounts and money-market funds the same?
No. An insured bank money-market deposit account is a deposit claim; a money-market mutual fund is a security and is not FDIC-insured.
Can an ordinary USDC token automatically earn the yield from its reserves?
No. Circle’s published USDC terms say holders do not receive the return generated on the reserves. Earning yield requires a separate product or investment arrangement.
Does the DN calculator recommend a product?
No. It performs simple scenario arithmetic for rates and fees users enter. Unknown risks, liquidity and legal protections are not converted into fake risk haircuts.
Sources, corrections and disclosures
Primary source links: US Treasury daily bill rates, FDIC deposit insurance, SEC money-market funds, and Circle USDC terms. DN authored the decision framework and calculator with AI-assisted drafting and primary-document review. Readers should seek personalised tax, regulatory and financial advice where relevant, and remember this article compares legal structures, not expected returns after unmodelled loss. Commercial referrals are disclosed above. Report dated corrections through DN editorial.




