Impermanent Loss: Compare LP Returns, Fees and Hedge Costs
Correction reviewed 13 November 2026. The previous version presented an unsupported “90%” loss-rate headline and described hedging as immunization. This article has no retained dataset establishing that percentage, and a hedge does not guarantee zero loss. The calculation below is a transparent, hypothetical full-range example, not evidence of investor outcomes.
Impermanent loss compares the value of an automated market maker position with the value of holding its starting assets over the same price move. That comparison is different from an absolute loss in reporting currency. An LP position can rise in value while finishing below the hold baseline. Fees can offset some or all of that relative shortfall; whether they do is an empirical question for the particular position and period.
1. Start with the right baseline
For a full-range 50/50 constant-product pair, assume the quote asset remains worth one reporting currency unit, initial capital is C, and the base asset’s final price divided by its initial price is r > 0. With unchanged liquidity and no fees, intervening deposits or withdrawals, the terminal values are:
- Hold starting assets: C × (1 + r) ÷ 2.
- LP before fees: C × √r.
- LP shortfall relative to hold: 2 × √r ÷ (1 + r) − 1.
The last expression is a relative comparison; multiply by 100 for percent. It is zero at r = 1 and negative when the price ratio moves away from its starting point. It does not estimate fees, funding, gas, liquidation, taxes or the cost of deploying additional hedge capital.
Concentrated liquidity needs a different calculation. The selected lower and upper bounds and the starting price matter. Uniswap documents that a concentrated position becomes inactive and stops earning fees after price leaves its range; it can become active again if price returns. At an out-of-range bound it holds one of the two tokens. This is not proof that every LP loses money or that a loss becomes unavoidable without a hedge. Source: Uniswap concentrated-liquidity documentation.
2. Compare a hypothetical LP position with holding
The worksheet uses the full-range baseline above. Enter earned fees, a separate hedge’s P&L and costs as independent same-period amounts in the same reporting currency. If the hedge P&L already includes a cost, do not enter that cost again. It does not calculate a hedge size, estimate a hedge’s outcome from the price move or choose a liquidity range.
DN Full-Range LP Illustration
Invented example inputs. No live data or account connection. Enter all five values; blank does not mean zero.
Calculate to inspect the invented example.
Input bounds for this illustration: capital above zero up to 1 billion; ratio above zero up to 1 million; fees and costs from zero to 1 billion; signed hedge P&L within ±1 billion; at most eight decimal places. Use ordinary decimals, without commas or exponent notation. These are worksheet limits, not venue rules. Arithmetic uses JavaScript floating-point numbers; displayed currency values round to two decimals.
Manual example: C = 1,000 and r = 4 produce a hold value of 2,500 and an LP value of 2,000 before fees: a 500 shortfall, or 20% relative to hold. Adding 100 of fees, a separately entered hedge loss of 50 and costs of 20 gives an adjusted LP amount of 2,030, which remains 470 below holding. These numbers are invented to show the calculation.
“Adjusted LP amount” is the modeled LP value plus the entered cashflows. It is not the value or return of the entire LP-and-hedge account: separate hedge collateral, its opportunity cost, cash transfers, path-dependent margin calls and tax are outside this worksheet. A positive difference does not make a proposed trade safe or establish that the entered fees or hedge result can be achieved.
3. Four questions before adding a hedge
- Which position is being measured? Record the pool contract, assets, fee tier, range and valuation time. A trading venue or derivatives interface is not automatically a concentrated-liquidity pool. Existing venue links: SynFutures, Drift, Astros (Code: 88SHOV). Verify the exact product independently.
- What additional exposure does the hedge introduce? A derivative may reduce selected directional exposure while adding funding, basis, margin, liquidation, counterparty and execution risks. No matching short position guarantees that the LP deposit is protected. Existing derivatives links: Bybit (Code: 46164), OKX (Code: 2136301), MEXC (Code: 16yJL), Bitget. Availability and suitability require product- and region-specific checks.
- Which action can the software actually perform? Confirm support for the intended pool, hedge venue, permissions and failure behavior before relying on automation. These links are not evidence of a verified LP rebalancing integration: Coinrule, Cryptohopper, 3Commas.
- What does the wallet authorize? A hardware wallet protects key handling but cannot make a malicious approval or unsafe contract harmless. Review the transaction, spender and permission scope. Existing hardware-wallet links: Ledger, OneKey (Code: 46Z9TD).
4. Keep the measurement record with the result
Save initial quantities, the valuation method and time, collected and uncollected fees, transaction costs and separate hedge cashflows. Compare the same assets and period against the hold baseline. For a concentrated position, use a range-aware method and retain the bounds; do not use the full-range worksheet as a substitute.
The following existing analytics and charting links are retained as related resources. Their presence does not establish support for a particular pool, tax treatment or automated hedge: ArbitrageScanner, ASCN AI, TradingView, Coinigy, CoinStats, Koinly. Verify coverage and permissions with the provider before use.




